My Student Loan Consolidation Adventure

Michael Lux Consolidation, Student Loan Blog 5 Comments

Editor’s Note: I consolidated my massive student loan debt in early 2013. My experience with student loan consolidation was part of why the Student Loan Sherpa came into existence.

Over the past few months, I have been working on my own federal student loan consolidation. With well over 100k in student loan debt, I’ve been very careful to ensure that this new consolidated loan would still be eligible for income-based repayment and the Public Service Loan Forgiveness plan. At this point, I could probably dedicate an entire blog entry just to the hold music I encountered.

After doing everything I possibly could to ensure that my consolidation went flawlessly, I was delighted with the initial results. After less than two weeks, I received a letter from MyFedLoan indicating they would be consolidating my student loans.  This would take place in 15 days unless I called to stop the process (this is the final warning because once your student loans are consolidated, there is no “unconsolidation“).

After waiting about two weeks, I anxiously logged on to to see my loan status. Sure enough, my new consolidated loans were there.  One was subsidized, and one was unsubsidized (they’re kept separate because the unsubsidized loans still carry a couple of perks this far into repayment). However, much to my dismay, all my old loans were still there, as well. As you can imagine, I was pretty shocked to see that my student loan debt had effectively doubled.

Double Student Loan Debt Panic

I immediately called MyFedLoan to find out what the problem was. I was fairly confident it was just a matter of updating their records. Given how much money their website said I owed, however, I wasn’t going to wait around. My conversation with them only made me more nervous.

When I called, I calmly explained that I had just consolidated my student loans.  Their website indicated I owed both the new consolidated loans AND the old loans. The lady on the phone was not the least bit surprised to hear this information.

Our exchange went something like this:

Me: Your website shows I owe double the debt.
MyFedLoan: Yeah, that happens.
Me: Can you please fix it? I don’t want you guys reporting to the credit agencies that I owe double.
MyFedLoan: Well, we don’t actually know that they are separate. You will have to call Direct Loan and ask them to fix it.
Me: What happened that would explain my debt showing up double?
MyFedLoan: Well, sometimes they tell us you have the new loan, but sometimes they forget to pay off the old ones.
Me:  They what? How often does this happen?
MyFedLoan: Oh, probably 1 or 2 in 50.

I have no idea how accurate her statistic was, but I was quite concerned. After asking a series of further questions and not getting any help whatsoever, I realized that this call would no longer be productive. I thanked her for her help and proceeded to call Direct Loan.

After being on hold with Direct Loan for about a decade (possibly an exaggeration), I was finally speaking with someone about my newly doubled debt. I explained my situation to the Direct Loan person on the phone.  She stated, “They should have gotten a check from us.” I agreed and told her, “They SHOULD have gotten a check but claim not to have received one.” She then told me that there was nothing she could do and take up the issue with MyFedLoan. I explained that MyFedLoan told me this was a Direct Loan issue and that they couldn’t fix it. So, I asked if they could communicate with each other and was told that this would never happen.

At this point, I asked if I could speak with a manager. When I was transferred and explained my situation for the third time, the manager said that he would “file a report” and that someone would investigate the issue. This sounded inadequate to me. I continued to ask questions regarding the purpose of filing a report, about when I could expect results, and about other reasons that could explain this issue.

Then, after well over an hour on the phone with three different people, he said, “It’s possible the check hasn’t cleared yet. Sometimes it can take longer than usual.” Sure enough, two days later, when I logged into MyFedLoan, all was right with my consolidation.

The Moral of the Story

Student loan consolidation can be very poorly organized. Sometimes double debt shows up, sometimes it’s because a check hasn’t cleared, and sometimes it’s because “they forgot to mail it.” This process can be a mess, and there is plenty of room for error. Thousands of your dollars are on the line, so pay close attention every step of the way.

[Further Reading: Should I Consolidate my $30,000 of Federal Student Loans?]

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I literally just saw the same thing happen to my loans and had a full blown panic attack. What was even worse was that their hours of operation are closed so I can’t contact them right away. What a horrible feeling it is to see that you now owe DOUBLE the amount. I’m sooo glad I saw your blog because once I read it, I realized they didn’t take off my old loans on my account as well. Hopefully I get it resolved without having as much of an issue as you. Thank you for being so clear on what had happened and reassuring me that it’s not the actual amount that I need to repay. Just knowing that will help me sleep better tonight!


I cosign everything Samantha just said. Thank you for sharing your experience. Now as I lay me down to sleep, my prayer is that I really am just “seeing double.” This HAS to be an error! **sigh… Thanks again, for hope!

Tonia Randall
Tonia Randall

Thank you . This just happened to me and how I came upon your blog. Thank you for the explanation.